Closing global knowledge gaps: Producing generalized knowledge from case studies of social-ecological systems

[en] Concerns over rapid widespread changes in social-ecological systems and their consequences for biodiversity, ecosystem functioning, food security, and human livelihoods are driving demands for globally comprehensive knowledge to support decision-making and policy development. Claims of regional or global knowledge about the patterns, causes, and significance of changes in social-ecological systems, or ‘generalized knowledge claims’ (GKCs), are generally produced by synthesis of evidence compiled from local and regional case study observations. GKCs now constitute a wide and varied body of research, yet they are also increasingly contested based on disagreements about their geographic, temporal, and/or thematic validity. There are no accepted guidelines for detecting biases or logical gaps between GKC’s and the evidence used to produce them. Here, we propose a typology of GKCs based on their evidence base and the process by which they are produced. The typology is structured by three dimensions: i) the prior state of knowledge about the phenomenon of interest; ii) the logic of generalization underlying the claim; and iii) the methodology for generalization. From this typology, we propose a standardized approach to assess the quality and commensurability of these dimensions for any given GKC, and their ability to produce robust and transparent knowledge based on constituent evidence. We then apply this approach to evaluate two contested GKCs – addressing global biodiversity and large-scale land acquisitions – and in doing so demonstrate a coherent approach to assessing and evaluating the scope and validity of GKCs. With this approach, GKCs can be produced and applied with greater transparency and accuracy, advancing the goal of actionable science on social-ecological systems.

Research center :

Luxembourg Centre for Socio-Environmental Systems (LCSES)

Disciplines :

Environmental sciences & ecology

Author, co-author :

Magliocca, Nicholas R

Ellis, Erle C

Allington, Ginger R.H.

de Bremond, Ariane

Dell’Angelo, Jampel

Mertz, Ole

Messerli, Peter

Meyfroidt, Patrick

SEPPELT, Ralf ; University of Luxembourg > Luxembourg Centre for Socio-Environmental Systems (LCSES)

Verburg, Peter H

External co-authors :

yes

Language :

English

Title :

Closing global knowledge gaps: Producing generalized knowledge from case studies of social-ecological systems

Publication date :

2018

Journal title :

Global Environmental Change: Human and Policy Dimensions

ISSN :

0959-3780

eISSN :

1872-9495

Volume :

Issue :

March

Pages :

1 - 14

Peer reviewed :

Peer Reviewed verified by ORBi

Focus Area :

Sustainable Development

Additional URL :

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2018.03.003

Available on ORBilu :

since 04 June 2025

Statistics

Number of views

41 (2 by Unilu)

Number of downloads

10 (0 by Unilu)

More statistics

Scopus citations^®

118

Scopus citations^®
without self-citations

OpenCitations

105

OpenAlex citations

134

Bibliography

An, L., Linderman, M., Qi, J., Shortridge, A., Liu, J., Exploring complexity in a human–environment system: an agent-based spatial model for multidisciplinary and multiscale integration. Ann. Assoc. Am. Geogr. 95:1 (2005), 54–79.
An, L., Brown, D.G., Nassauer, J.I., Low, B., Variations in development of exurban residential landscapes: timing, location, and driving forces. J. Land Use Sci. 6:1 (2011), 13–32.
Allan, J.A., Virtual water-the water, food, and trade nexus. useful concept or misleading metaphor?. Water Int. 28:1 (2003), 106–113.
Bäckstrand, K., Lövbrand, E., Planting trees to mitigate climate change: contested discourses of ecological modernization, green governmentality and civic environmentalism. Global Environ. Politics 6:1 (2006), 50–75.
Bradley, N.L., Leopold, A.C., Ross, J., Huffaker, W., Phenological changes reflect climate change in Wisconsin. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 96:17 (1999), 9701–9704.
Breu, T., Bader, C., Messerli, P., Heinimann, A., Rist, S., Eckert, S., Large-scale land acquisition and its effects on the water balance in investor and host countries. PloS one, 11(3), 2016, e0150901.
Cabral, L., Shankland, A., Narratives of Brazil-Africa cooperation for agricultural development: new paradigms?. China Braz. Afr. Agric. (CBAA) Project Working Pap. 51 (2013), 1–27.
Cleland, E.E., Chuine, I., Menzel, A., Mooney, H.A., Schwartz, M.D., Shifting plant phenology in response to global change. Trends Ecol. Evol. 22:7 (2007), 357–365.
Colomina, I., Molina, P., Unmanned aerial systems for photogrammetry and remote sensing: a review. ISPRS J. Photogramm. Remote Sens. 92 (2014), 79–97.
Costanza, R., Funtowicz, S.O., Ravetz, J.R., Assessing and communicating data quality in policy-relevant research. Environ. Manage. 16:1 (1992), 121–131.
Dell'Angelo, J., D'Odorico, P., Rulli, M.C., Marchand, P., The tragedy of the grabbed commons: coercion and dispossession in the global land rush. World Dev., 2017, 10.1016/j.worlddev.2016.11.005.
Dell'Angelo, J., D'Odorico, P.Rulli, The global water grabbing syndrome. Ecol. Econ., 2017 in press.
Ebbinghaus, B., When less is more selection problems in large-N and small-N cross-national comparisons. Int. Sociol. 20:2 (2005), 133–152.
Ellis, E.C., Maslin, M., Boivin, Nicole, Bauer, A., Involving social scientists in defining the anthropocene. Nature 540 (2016), 192–193.
DeFries, R., Hansen, A., Turner, B.L., Reid, R., Liu, J., Land use change around protected areas: management to balance human needs and ecological function. Ecol. Appl. 17:4 (2007), 1031–1038.
Funtowicz, S.O., Ravetz, J.R., Uncertainty and Quality in Science for Policy. 1991, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
Geist, H.J., Lambin, E.F., Proximate causes and underlying driving forces of tropical deforestation tropical forests are disappearing as the result of many pressures, both local and regional, acting in various combinations in different geographical locations. BioScience 52:2 (2002), 143–150.
George, A.L., Bennett, A., Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. 2005, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Gerstner, K., Dormann, C.F., Stein, A., Manceur, A.M., Seppelt, R., Editor's choice: review: effects of land use on plant diversity–a global meta‐analysis. J. Appl. Ecol. 51:6 (2014), 1690–1700.
Gerstner, K., Moreno-Mateos, D., Gurevitch, J., Beckmann, M., Kambach, S., Jones, H.P., Seppelt, R., Will your paper be used in a meta‐analysis? make the reach of your research broader and longer lasting. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 2017.
Gonzalez, A., Cardinale, B.J., Allington, G.R., Byrnes, J., Arthur Endsley, K., Brown, D.G., Hooper, D.U., Isbell, F., O'Connor, M.I., Loreau, M., Estimating local biodiversity change: a critique of papers claiming no net loss of local diversity. Ecology 97:8 (2016), 1949–1960, 10.1890/15-1759.1.
Grau, H.R., Aide, M., Globalization and land-use transitions in latin America. Ecol. Soc., 13(2), 2008, 16.
Grimm, V., Revilla, E., Berger, U., Jeltsch, F., Mooij, W.M., Railsback, S.F., Thulke, H.-H., Weiner, J., Wiegand, T., DeAngelis, D.L., Pattern-oriented modeling of agent-based complex systems: lessons from ecology. Science 310 (2005), 987–991.
Hansen, M.C., Potapov, P.V., Moore, R., Hancher, M., Turubanova, S.A., Tyukavina, A., Thau, D., Stehman, S.V., Goetz, S.J., Loveland, T.R., Kommareddy, A., High-resolution global maps of 21st-century forest cover change. Science 342:6160 (2013), 850–853.
Henrich, J., Boyd, R., Bowles, S., Camerer, C., Fehr, E., Gintis, H., McElreath, R., Alvard, M., Barr, A., Ensminger, J., Henrich, N.S., “Economic man” in cross-cultural perspective: behavioral experiments in 15 small-scale societies. Behav. Brain Sci. 28:6 (2005), 795–815.
Hersperger, A.M., Bürgi, M., Going beyond landscape change description: quantifying the importance of driving forces of landscape change in a Central Europe case study. Land Use Policy 26 (2009), 640–648, 10.1016/j.landusepol.2008.08.015.
Hochstetler, K., Kostka, G., Wind and solar power in Brazil and China: interests, state–business relations, and policy outcomes. Global Environ. Politics 15:3 (2015), 74–94.
Kaimowitz, D., Angelsen, A., Economic Models of Tropical Deforestation: A Review. 1998, Center for International Forestry Research, Bogor, Indonesia.
Karl, J.W., Herrick, J.E., Unnasch, R.S., Gillan, J.K., Ellis, E.C., Lutters, W.G., Martin, L.J., Discovering ecologically-relevant knowledge from published studies through geo-semantic searching. BioScience 63 (2013), 674–682.
Keys, E., McConnell, W.J., Global change and the intensification of agriculture in the tropics. Global Environ. Change 15:4 (2005), 320–337.
Koricheva, J., Gurevitch, J., Mengersen, K., Handbook of Meta-analysis in Ecology and Evolution, 2013, Princeton University Press.
Laney, R.M., Disaggregating induced intensification for land-change analysis: a case study from Madagascar. Ann. Assoc. Am. Geogr. 92:4 (2002), 702–726.
Liberati, A., Altman, D.G., Tetzlaff, J., Mulrow, C., Gøtzsche, P.C., Ioannidis, J.P., Clarke, M., Devereaux, P.J., Kleijnen, J., Moher, D., The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. Ann. Intern. Med., 151(4), 2009, 10.7326/0003-4819-151-4-200908180-00136 W-65-W-94.
Lillesand, T., Kiefer, R.W., Chipman, J., Remote Sensing and Image Interpretation. 2014, John Wiley & Sons.
MacDonald, G.K., Bennett, E.M., Taranu, Z.E., The influence of time, soil characteristics, and land‐use history on soil phosphorus legacies: a global meta‐analysis. Glob. Change Biol. 18:6 (2012), 1904–1917.
Magliocca, N.R., Model-based synthesis of locally contingent responses to global market signals. Land, 4(3), 2015, 807, 10.3390/land4030807.
Magliocca, N.R., Rudel, T.K., Verburg, P.H., McConnell, W.J., Mertz, O., Gerstner, K., Heinimann, A., Ellis, E.C., Synthesis in land change science: methodological patterns, challenges, and guidelines. Reg. Environ. Change 15:2 (2015), 211–226.
Margulies, J.D., Magliocca, N.R., Schmill, M.D., Ellis, E.C., Ambiguous geographies: connecting case study knowledge with global change science. Ann. the Am. Assoc. Geogr. 106:3 (2016), 572–596.
Marston, S.A., The social construction of scale. Prog. Hum. Geogr. 24:2 (2000), 219–242.
Martin, L.J., Blossey, B., Ellis, E.C., Mapping where ecologists work: biases in the global distribution of terrestrial ecological observations. Front. Ecol. Environ. 10:4 (2012), 195–201.
Mather, A.S., The forest transition. Area 24 (1992), 367–379.
McMichael, C.N.H., Matthews-Bird, F., Farfan-Rios, W., Feeley, K.J., Ancient human disturbances may be skewing our understanding of Amazonian forests. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114 (2017), 522–527.
Messerli, P., Heinimann, A., Giger, M., Breu, T., Schönweger, O., From ‘land grabbing’ to sustainable investments in land: potential contributions by land change science. Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 5 (2013), 528–534.
Meyfroidt, P., Environmental cognitions, land change and social-ecological feedbacks: local case studies of forest transition in Vietnam. Hum. Ecol. 41:3 (2013), 367–392, 10.1007/s10745-012-9560-x.
Meyfroidt, P., Approaches and terminology for causal analysis in land systems science. J. Land Use Sci., 2016, 1–27.
Meyfroidt, P., Carlson, K.M., Fagan, M.E., Gutiérrez-Vélez, V.H., Macedo, M.N., Curran, L.M., DeFries, R.S., Dyer, G.A., Gibbs, H.K., Lambin, E.F., Morton, D.C., Robiglio, V., Multiple pathways of commodity crop expansion in tropical forest landscapes. Environ. Res. Lett., 9, 2014, 074012, 10.1088/1748-9326/9/7/074012.
Munroe, D.K., McSweeney, K., Olson, J.L., Mansfield, B., Using economic geography to reinvigorate land-change science. Geoforum 52 (2014), 12–21.
Newbold, T., Hudson, L.N., Hill, S.L., Contu, S., Lysenko, I., Senior, R.A., Börger, L., Bennett, D.J., Choimes, A., Collen, B., Day, J., et al. Global effects of land use on local terrestrial biodiversity. Nature 520:7545 (2015), 45–50.
Oberlack, C., Tejada, L., Messerli, P., Rist, S., Giger, M., Sustainable livelihoods in the global land rush? archetypes of livelihood vulnerability and sustainability potentials. Global Environ. Change 41 (2016), 153–171.
Ostrom, E., A diagnostic approach for going beyond panaceas. Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences 104:39 (2007), 15181–15187, 10.1073/pnas.0702288104 USA.
Palmer, M.A., Kramer, J.G., Boyd, J., Hawthorne, D., Practices for facilitating interdisciplinary synthetic research: the national socio-environmental synthesis center (SESYNC). Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 19 (2016), 111–122.
Parmesan, C., Yohe, G., A globally coherent fingerprint of climate change impacts across natural systems. Nature 421:6918 (2003), 37–42.
Ragin, C.C., The Comparative Method. 1987, University of California Press, Berkeley.
Rasmussen, K., D'haen, S., Fensholt, R., Fog, B., Horion, S., Nielsen, J.O., Rasmussen, L.V., Reenberg, A., Environmental change in the Sahel: reconciling contrasting evidence and interpretations. Reg. Environ. Change 16:3 (2016), 673–680.
Rihoux, B., Ragin, C.C., Configurational Comparative Methods: Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) and Related Techniques. Sage: Chicago, 2009.
Rindfuss, R.R., Walsh, S.J., Turner, B.L. II, Fox, J., Mishra, V., Developing a science of land change: challenges and methodological issues. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 101 (2004), 13976–13981.
Robinson, W.S., Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals. Am. Sociol. Rev. 15:3 (1950), 351–357.
Rudel, T.K., Meta-analyses of case studies: a method for studying regional and global environmental change. Global Environ. Change 18 (2008), 18–25.
Rudel, T., Flesher, K., Bates, D., Baptista, S., Holmgren, P., The tropical deforestation literature: geographical and historical patterns of information. Unasylva 51 (2000), 46–53.
Rudel, T.K., Coomes, O.T., Moran, E., Achard, F., Angelsen, A., Xu, J., Lambin, E., Forest transitions: towards a global understanding of the land use change. Global Environ. Change 15 (2005), 23–31.
Rudel, T.K., Defries, R., Asner, G.P., Laurance, W.F., Changing drivers of deforestation and new opportunities for conservation. Conserv. Biol. 23:6 (2009), 1396–1405.
Schmill, M.D., Gordon, L.M., Magliocca, N.R., Ellis, E.C., Oates, T., GLOBE: analytics for assessing global representativeness. Computing for Geospatial Research and Application (COM. Geo), 2014 Fifth International Conference, 2014, IEEE, 25–32.
Seppelt, R., Manceur, A.M., Liu, J., Fenichel, E.P., Klotz, S., Synchronized peak-rate years of global resources use. Ecol. Soci., 19, 2014, 10.5751/ES-07039-190450 art50.
Steffen, W., Persson, Å., Deutsch, L., Zalasiewicz, J., Williams, M., Richardson, K., Crumley, C., Crutzen, P., Folke, C., Gordon, L., Molina, M., Ramanathan, V., Rockström, J., Scheffer, M., Schellnhuber, H.J., Svedin, U., The Anthropocene: from global change to planetary stewardship. Ambio 40:7 (2011), 739–761.
Steinberg, P.F., Can we generalize from case studies?. Global Environ. Politics 15:3 (2015), 152–175, 10.1162/GLEP_a_00316.
Suweis, S., Carr, J.A., Maritan, A., Rinaldo, A., D'Odorico, P., Resilience and reactivity of global food security. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 112:22 (2015), 6902–6907.
Tamea, S., Laio, F., Ridolfi, L., Global effects of local food-production crises: a virtual water perspective. Sci. Rep., 6, 2016.
Taub, D.R., Miller, B., Allen, H., Effects of elevated CO2 on the protein concentration of food crops: a meta‐analysis. Glob. Change Biol. 14:3 (2008), 565–575.
Turner, B.L., Ali, A.S., Induced intensification: agricultural change in Bangladesh with implications for Malthus and Boserup. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 93:25 (1996), 14984–14991.
Turner, B.L., Kasperson, R.E., Meyer, W.B., Dow, K.M., Golding, D., Kasperson, J.X., Mitchell, R.C., Ratick, S.J., Two types of global environmental change: definitional and spatial-scale issues in their human dimensions. Global Environ. Change 1:1 (1990), 14–22.
Turner, B.L., Lambin, E.F., Reenberg, A., The emergence of land change science for global environmental change and sustainability. PNAS 104:52 (2007), 20666–20671.
Václavík, T., Langerwisch, F., Cotter, M., Fick, J., Häuser, I., Hotes, S., et al. Investigating potential transferability of place-based research in land system science. Environ. Res. Lett., 11, 2016, 95002, 10.1088/1748-9326/11/9/095002.
Valbuena, D., Verburg, P.H., Bregt, A.K., Ligtenberg, A., An agent-based approach to model land-use change at a regional scale. Landsc. Ecol. 25:2 (2010), 185–199.
van der Sluijs, J.P., Craye, M., Funtowicz, S., Kloprogge, P., Ravetz, J., Risbey, J., Combining quantitative and qualitative measures of uncertainty in model‐based environmental assessment: the NUSAP system. Risk Anal. 25:2 (2005), 481–492.
van Vliet, J., Magliocca, N.R., Büchner, B., Cook, E., Benayas, J.M.R., Ellis, E.C., Heinimann, A., Keys, E., Lee, T.M., Mertz, O., Meta-studies in land use science: current coverage and prospects. Ambio 45:1 (2015), 15–28.
van Vliet, J., de Groot, H.L., Rietveld, P., Verburg, P.H., Manifestations and underlying drivers of agricultural land use change in Europe. Landsc. Urban Plan. 133 (2015), 24–36.
van Vliet, N., Mertz, O., Heinimann, A., Trends, drivers and impacts of changes in swidden cultivation in tropical forest-agriculture frontiers: a global assessment. Global Environ. Change 22:2 (2012), 418–429.
Vandergeten, E., Azadi, H., Teklemariam, D., Nyssen, J., Witlox, F., Vanhaute, E., Agricultural outsourcing or land grabbing: a meta-analysis. Landsc. Ecol. 31:7 (2016), 1395–1417.
Vayda, A.P., Progressive contextualization: methods for research in human ecology. Hum. Ecol. 11 (1983), 265–281.
Vellend, M., Baeten, L., Myers-Smith, I.H., Elmendorf, S.C., Beauséjour, R., Brown, C.D., De Frenne, P., Verheyen, K., Wipf, S., Global meta-analysis reveals no net change in local-scale plant biodiversity over time. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110:48 (2013), 19456–19459.
Verburg, P.H., Van De Steeg, J., Veldkamp, A., Willemen, L., From land cover change to land function dynamics: a major challenge to improve land characterization. J. Environ. Manage. 90:3 (2009), 1327–1335.
Verburg, P.H., Ellis, E.C., Letourneau, A., A global assessment of market accessibility and market influence for global environmental change studies. Environ. Res. Lett., 6(3), 2011, 034019.
Verburg, P.H., Neumann, K., Nol, L., Challenges in using land use and land cover data for global change studies. Global Change Biol. 17:2 (2011), 974–989.
Walton, D., Abductive Reasoning. 2005, University of Alabama Press.
Young, O.R., Lambin, E.F., Alcock, F., Haberl, H., Karlsson, S.I., McConnell, W.J., Myint, T., Pahl-Wostl, C., Polsky, C., Ramakrishnan, P., Schroeder, H., Scouvart, M., Verburg, P.H., A portfolio approach to analyzing complex human-environment interactions: institutions and land change. Ecol. Soc., 11(2), 2006, 31 [online] URL http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol11/iss2/art31/.