Reference : The Human Rights Defence in International Investment Arbitration: Exploring the Limti...
Scientific journals : Article
Law, criminology & political science : European & international law
Law / European Law
The Human Rights Defence in International Investment Arbitration: Exploring the Limtis of Systemic Integration
Fahner, Johannes mailto [University of Amsterdam]
Happold, Matthew mailto [University of Luxembourg > Faculty of Law, Economics and Finance (FDEF) > Law Research Unit >]
International and Comparative Law Quarterly
Cambridge University Press
United Kingdom
[en] Public international law ; International investment arbitration ; Human rights ; Law of treaties
[en] In a variety of investment arbitration cases, respondent States have argued that the measure
complained of by the investor was mandated by the State’s human rights obligations. This defence raises intricate questions concerning the relationship between international investment law and human rights law. Tribunals have generally been reluctant to engage with the argument and to interpret the relationship between investment law and human rights in a straightforward manner. This article discusses two other possibilities: harmonious interpretation and prioritisation. Harmonious interpretation seeks to read provisions from investment treaties and human rights treaties together, whereas prioritisation gives normative superiority to one provision over another. We conclude that harmonious interpretation is facilitated by the discretionary character of common treaty standards in both human rights and investment law, but that the final result is not likely to be very different from prioritisation, because even harmonious interpretation requires that one provision is read in the light of, and thereby subjugated to, another provision.
Researchers ; Professionals ; Students

File(s) associated to this reference

Fulltext file(s):

Limited access
human_rights_defence_in_international_investment_arbitration_exploring_the_limits_of_systemic_integration.pdfPublisher postprint235.71 kBRequest a copy

Bookmark and Share SFX Query

All documents in ORBilu are protected by a user license.