Covid-19; Narratives of crisis; Crisis response; Narrative network analysis
Abstract :
[en] Crisis narratives shape public understanding and, consequently, the response to the crisis itself. In the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, when in February 2020 Italy was experiencing more cases than any other country, the Italian response to the crisis originated debates over how to best respond to the outbreak. Informed by Critical Discourse Analysis theory and using narrative networks as a framework for the critical analysis of narratives, this study analyzes the discourse strategies employed by experts, politicians and other social actors from Spain, France, the Netherlands, and the UK when presenting their domestic measures in relation to Italy's response to coronavirus. The analysis shows that the narratives attached to nation-specific decisions were highly culturalized and connected to country-specific shared experiences, such as a sense of national exceptionalism built in opposition with the denigration of Italy as the Other-identity. Attribution of blame and blameworthiness was also found to be a common pattern across countries according to which Italians were framed as wrongdoers but also as deserving blame. The article also presents a comprehensive “timeline of narratives” which opens avenues for a critical reflection on the impact such narratives may have had on the understanding of the crisis, including the creation of a negative climate of division and inappropriate crisis responses.
Research center :
- Luxembourg Centre for Contemporary and Digital History (C2DH) > Digital History & Historiography (DHI)
Disciplines :
Languages & linguistics
Author, co-author :
VIOLA, Lorella ; University of Luxembourg > Luxembourg Centre for Contemporary and Digital History (C2DH) > DHARPA
External co-authors :
no
Language :
English
Title :
“Italy, for example, is just incredibly stupid now”. European crisis narrations in relation to Italy’s response to COVID-19
scite shows how a scientific paper has been cited by providing the context of the citation, a classification describing whether it supports, mentions, or contrasts the cited claim, and a label indicating in which section the citation was made.
Bibliography
Amante A. Anzolin E. (2020). First Italian dies of coronavirus as outbreak flares in north. Reuters. Available online at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-health-italy-idUSKBN20F0UI (accessed February 21, 2020).
Anthony L (2019). AntConc 3.5.8. Waseda University. Available online at: http://www.antlab.sci.waseda.ac.jp/
Arceneaux K. Johnson M. (2013). Changing Minds or Changing Channels? Partisan News in an Age of Choice. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Atkinson M. L (2017). Combative Politics: The Media and Public Perceptions of Lawmaking. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Bajaj G. Khandelwal S. Budhwar P. (2021). COVID-19 pandemic and the impact of cross-cultural differences on crisis management: a conceptual model of transcultural crisis management. Int. J. Cross Cult. Manag. 21, 569–601. 10.1177/14705958211060189
Baker P. Gabrielatos C. McEnery T. (2013). Discourse Analysis and Media Attitudes: The Representation of Islam in the British Press. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
BBC News (2020). Coronavirus: Italy Extends Emergency Measures Nationwide. BBC News. Available online at: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-51810673 (accessed March 10, 2020).
Bearman P. S. Stovel K. (2000). Becoming a Nazi: a model for narrative networks. Poetics 27, 69–90. 10.1016/S0304-422X(99)00022-4
Berliner Morgenpost (2020). Coronavirus: Interaktive Karte zeigt aktuelle Zahl der Corona-Infektionen in Deutschland, Europa und weltweit. Berliner Morgenpost. Available online at: https://interaktiv.morgenpost.de/corona-virus-karte-infektionen-deutschland-weltweit/ (accessed September 29, 2020).
BFM TV (2020). Olivier Véran sur le confinement: “L'Italie fait face à une très grande détresse de son système hospitalier.” Available online at: https://www.bfmtv.com/politique/olivier-veran-sur-le-confinement-l-italie-fait-face-a-une-tres-grande-detresse-de-son-systeme-hospitalier_VN-202003090224.html (accessed March 9, 2020).
Boydstun A. E (2013). Making the News: Politics, the Media, and Agenda Setting. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Brooks B (2020). Like the flu? Trump's coronavirus messaging confuses public, pandemic researchers say. Reuters. Available online at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-mixed-messages-idUSKBN2102GY (accessed March 14 2020).
Bryant J. Zillmann D. Bryant J. Oliver M. B. (Eds.). (2002). Media Effects: Advances in Theory and Research (2nd ed.). London: Routledge.
Coombs W. T (2007). Protecting organization reputations during a crisis: the development and application of situational crisis communication theory. Corp. Reput. Rev. 10, 163–176. 10.1057/palgrave.crr.1550049
Corriere della Sera (2020). Coronavirus, primi due casi in Italia: Sono due turisti cinesi. Corriere della Sera. Available online at: https://www.corriere.it/cronache/20_gennaio_30/coronavirus-italia-corona-9d6dc436-4343-11ea-bdc8-faf1f56f19b7.shtml (accessed January 30 2020)
Douglas K. M (2021). COVID-19 conspiracy theories. Group Process. Intergroup Relat. 24, 270–275. 10.1177/1368430220982068
Drosten C. Günther S. Preiser W. van der Werf S. Brodt H.-R. Becker S. et al. (2003). Identification of a novel coronavirus in patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome. New Engl. J. Med. 348, 1967–1976. 10.1056/NEJMoa03074712690091
Edwards D (1997). Discourse and Cognition (pp. vii, 356). Thousand OAKS, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.
El Mundo (2020). Críticas a Italia por la gestión de la epidemia de coronavirus. El Mundo. Available online at: https://www.elmundo.es/ciencia-y-salud/salud/2020/03/02/5e5c0bb0fc6c838e278b4683.html (accessed March 2 2020)
Entman R. M (2003). Projections of Power: Framing News, Public Opinion, and U.S. Foreign Policy (Studies in communication, media, and public opinion). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Fairclough N. Wodak R. (1997). “Critical discourse analysis,” in Discourse Studies: A Multidisciplinary Introduction (Vol. 2), ed T. van Dijk (Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE).
Fidler D (2004). SARS, Governance and the Globalization of Disease. London: Palgrave Macmillan
Gimenez J (2010). Narrative Analysis in Linguistic Research, ed. L. Litosseliti. Continuum, 198–215. Available online at: https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/9650z/narrative-analysis-in-linguistic-research (accessed February 07, 2022).
GOV.UK (2020). COVID-19: Government Announces Moving Out of Contain Phase and Into Delay. GOV.UK. Available online at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/covid-19-government-announces-moving-out-of-contain-phase-and-into-delay (accessed March 12, 2020).
Guzmán P. J (2020). Fernando Simón: ≪El 90% de los casos de coronavirus en España proceden de Italia≫. Newtral. Available online at: https://www.newtral.es/fernando-simon-el-90-de-los-casos-de-coronavirus-en-espana-proceden-de-italia/20200302/ (accessed March 2, 2020).
Jäger S (2001). “Discourse and knowledge: theoretical and methodological aspects of a critical discourse and dispositive analysis,” in Methods of critical discourse analysis, eds R. Wodak and M. Meyer (Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE), 32–62.
Ksiazek T. G. Erdman D. Goldsmith C. S. Zaki S. R. Peret T. Emery S. et al. (2003). A novel coronavirus associated with severe acute respiratory syndrome. New Engl. J. Med. 348, 1953–1966. 10.1056/NEJMoa03078112690092
LeDuc J. W. Barry M. A. (2004). SARS, the first pandemic of the 21st Century1. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 10, e26. 10.3201/eid1011.040797_0215152053
Nos.nl (2020). Crisis-Experts: Onze Corona-Aanpak Is Goed, Communicatie Kan Beter. Available online at: https://nos.nl/l/2326736 (accessed March 11, 2020)
Patrona M (2006). Conversationalization and media empowerment in Greek television discussion programs. Discourse Soc. 17, 5–27. 10.1177/0957926506058062
Patrona M (2012). Journalists on the news: the structured panel discussion as a form of broadcast talk. Discourse Soc. 23, 145–162. 10.1177/0957926511431505
Patrona M (2018). Crisis and the Media. In Dapsac.76. John Benjamins Publishing Company. Available online at: https://benjamins.com/catalog/dapsac.76
Potter J. Edwards D. Wetherell M. (2016). A model of discourse in action: Am. Behav. Sci. 36, 383–401. 10.1177/0002764293036003008
Potter J. Wetherell M. (1987). Discourse and Social Psychology: Beyond Attitudes and Behaviour. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc, 216
Pummerer L. Böhm R. Lilleholt L. Winter K. Zettler I. Sassenberg K. (2022). Conspiracy theories and their societal effects during the COVID-19 pandemic. Social Psychol. Personal. Sci. 13, 49–59. 10.1177/19485506211000217
Ratto Trabucco F (2020). Riflessioni sui D.P.C.M. marzolini “di salute pubblica” sull'emergenza Coronavirus con limitazioni draconiane ai diritti costituzionali a mezzo atto amministrativo. lexitalia.it. Giuriconsult s.r.l. editor, Palermo.
Reuters L. F. avec A. et (2020). Coronavirus: Cinq nouveaux cas en France annonce Buzyn, deux écoles fermées en Haute-Savoie. Le Figaro.fr. Available online at: https://www.lefigaro.fr/sciences/coronavirus-5-nouveaux-cas-en-france-20200208 (accessed February 8, 2020).
Reynolds B. and W. Seeger M. (2005). Crisis and emergency risk communication as an integrative model. J. Health Commun. 10, 43–55. 10.1080/1081073059090457115764443
Roser M. Ritchie H. Ortiz-Ospina E. Hasell J. (2020). Coronavirus Pandemic (COVID-19). Our World in Data. Available online at: https://ourworldindata.org/coronavirus (accessed February 07, 2022).
Safi M. Giuffrida A. Farrer M. (2020). Coronavirus: Italy Bans Any Movement Inside Country As Toll Nears 5,500. The Guardian. Available online at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/22/italian-pm-warns-of-worst-crisis-since-ww2-as-coronavirus-deaths-leap-by-almost-800 (accessed March 22, 2020).
Saunders B. Sim J. Kingstone T. Baker S. Waterfield J. Bartlam B. et al. (2018). Saturation in qualitative research: exploring its conceptualization and operationalization. Qual. Quant. 52, 1893–1907. 10.1007/s11135-017-0574-829937585
Seeger M. Sellnow T. L. (2016). Narratives of Crisis: Telling Stories of Ruin and Renewal. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Stein R. A. Ometa O. Pachtman Shetty S. Katz A. Popitiu M. I. Brotherton R. (2021). Conspiracy theories in the era of COVID-19: a tale of two pandemics. Int. J. Clin. Pract. 75:e13778. 10.1111/ijcp.1377833480171
Stokes J (2021). How to do Media and Cultural Studies. London: Sage.
United Nations (2020). UN Tackles ‘Infodemic' of Misinformation and Cybercrime in COVID-19 Crisis. United Nations; United Nations. Available online at: https://www.un.org/en/un-coronavirus-communications-team/un-tackling-%E2%80%98infodemic%E2%80%99-misinformation-and-cybercrime-covid-19 (accessed March, 28, 2020)
USA Today (2020). Top Disease Official: Risk of Coronavirus in USA is “Minuscule”; Skip Mask and Wash Hands. USA TODAY. Available online at: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2020/02/17/nih-disease-official-anthony-fauci-risk-of-coronavirus-in-u-s-is-minuscule-skip-mask-and-wash-hands/4787209002/ (accessed February 17, 2020).
Valeurs actuelles (2020). Coronavirus: Après avoir critiqué l'Italie, la France s'en inspire. Valeurs actuelles. Available online at: https://www.valeursactuelles.com/politique/coronavirus-apres-avoir-critique-litalie-la-france-sen-inspire-117319 (accessed March 20, 2020).
van Dijk T. A. (ed.) (1985). Discourse and Communication: New Approaches to the Analysis of Mass Media Discourse and Communication. Berlin: De Gruyter.
WHO (2020a). Statement on the Second Meeting of the International Health Regulations(2005). Emergency Committee Regarding the Outbreak of Novel Coronavirus (2019-nCoV). Available online at: https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/30-01-2020-statement-on-the-second-meeting-of-the-international-health-regulations-(2005)-emergency-committee-regarding-the-outbreak-of-novel-coronavirus-(2019-ncov) (accessed January 30, 2020).
WHO (2020b). WHO Director-General's Opening Remarks at the Media Briefing on COVID-19-−11 March 2020. Available online at: https://www.who.int/dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general-s-opening-remarks-at-the-media-briefing-on-covid-19-11-march-2020 (accessed March 11, 2020)
WHO (2020c). Public Health Criteria to Adjust Public Health and Social Measures in the Context of COVID-19. Available online at: https://www.who.int/publications-detail-redirect/public-health-criteria-to-adjust-public-health-and-social-measures-in-the-context-of-covid-19 (accessed May 12, 2020)
WHO|Novel Coronavirus—China (2020). WHO; World Health Organization. Available online at: http://www.who.int/csr/don/12-january-2020-novel-coronavirus-china/en/ (accessed January 12, 2020).
Wodak R. Angouri J. (2014). From grexit to grecovery: euro/crisis discourses. Discourse Soc. 25, 417–423. 10.1177/0957926514536967
Wodak R. Meyer M. (2001). Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
Yle Uutiset (2020). Finland's First Coronavirus Case Confirmed in Lapland. Yle Uutiset. Available online at: https://yle.fi/uutiset/osasto/news/finlands_first_coronavirus_case_confirmed_in_lapland/11182855 (accessed January 29, 2020).
