Screening criteria; conjoint analysis; human capital; education; experience
Abstract :
[en] We assess whether and how VC investors’ education and experience influence their screening decisions of potential investee candidates. Empirically, we perform an experimental choice-based-conjoint (CBC) analysis with 564 individual VC investors. Our results highlight that the level and field of education, as well as the decision maker’s investment and entrepreneurial experience, moderate the relative importance of different screening criteria. More specifically, we find that international scalability seems to become more important for decision makers with higher education and those with entrepreneurial experience. Whereas decision makers with a background in natural science focus on the value-added of the product or service, engineers seem to value a break even profitability and focus less on the management team. Investment experience, on the other hand, leads to a stronger focus on the management team. Our study contributes to the literature investigating the influence of human capital characteristics of the decision maker in venture financing. Practical implications exist for entrepreneurial ventures seeking financing and for risk capital investors making investments in such ventures.
Aguinis H, Gottfredson RK, Culpepper SA (2013) Best-practice recommendations for estimating cross-level interaction effects using multilevel modeling. J Manag 39(6):1490–1528
Bachher JS, Guild PD (1996) Financing early stage technology based companies: investment criteria used by investors. Front Entrep Res 996:363–376
Bantel KA, Jackson SE (1989) Top management and innovations in banking: does the composition of the top team make a difference. Strateg Manag J 10(1):107–124
Baron RA, Ensley MD (2006) Opportunity recognition as the detection of meaningful patterns: evidence from comparisons of novice and experienced entrepreneurs. Manage Sci 52(9):133–344
Becker GS (1964) Human capital. Columbia University Press, New York City.10.1093/nq/s1-IV.92.83-a
Bliss RT (1999) A venture capital model for transitioning economies: the case of Poland. Ventur Cap 1(3):241–257
Block J, Fisch C, Vismara S, Andres R (2019) Private equity investment criteria: an experimental conjoint analysis of venture capital business angels, and family offices. J Corp Finan 58:329–352
Block J, Hirschmann M, Fisch C (2021) Which criteria matter when impact investors screen social enterprises? J Corp Finan 66:101813
Bonner SE (1990) Experience effects in auditing: the role of task-specific knowledge. Account Rev 65(1):72–92
Boocock G, Woods M (1997) The evaluation criteria used by venture capitalists: evidence from a UK Venture Fund. Int Small Bus J 16(1):36–57
Carpenter MA, Geletkancz MA, Sanders WG (2004) Upper echelons research revisited: Antecedents, elements, and consequences of top management team composition. J Manag 30(6):749–778. 10.1016/j.jm.2004.06.001 DOI: 10.1016/j.jm.2004.06.001
Carter RB, Van Auken HE (1992) Effect of professional background on venture capital proposal evaluation. J Small Bus Strateg 3(1):45–55
Chan CS, Park HD (2015) How images and color in business plans influence venture investment screening decisions. J Bus Ventur 30(5):732–748
Chrzan K, Orme B (2000) An overview and comparison of design strategies for choice-based conjoint analysis. Sawtooth Software Research Paper Series
Croce A, Martí J, Murtinu S (2013) The impact of venture capital on the productivity growth of European entrepreneurial firms: ‘screening’ or ‘value added’ effect? J Bus Ventur 28(4):489–510
Datta S, Iskandar-Datta M (2014) Upper-echelon executive human capital and compensation: generalist vs specialist skills. Strateg Manag J 35(12):1853–1866
Davidsson P, Steffens P, Fitzsimmons J (2009) Growing profitable or growing from profits: putting the horse in front of the cart? J Bus Ventur 24(4):388–406
Delmar F, Shane S (2006) Does experience matter? The effect of founding team experience on the survival and sales of newly founded ventures. Strateg Organ 4(3):215–247. 10.1177/1476127006066596 DOI: 10.1177/1476127006066596
Delmar F, McKelvie A, Wennberg K (2013) Untangling the relationships among growth, profitability and survival in new firms. Technovation 33(8–9):276–291
Dimov DP, Shepherd DA (2005) Human capital theory and venture capital firms: exploring “home runs” and “strike outs.” J Bus Ventur 20(1):1–21
Dimov D, Shepherd DA, Sutcliffe KM (2007) Requisite expertise, firm reputation, and status in venture capital investment allocation decisions. J Bus Ventur 22(4):481–502
Elango B, Fried VH, Hisrich RD, Polonchek A (1995) How venture capital firms differ. J Bus Ventur 10(2):157–179
Feeney L, Haines GH, Riding AL (1999) Private investors investment criteria: insights from qualitative data. Venture Cap 1(2):121–145
Fernhaber S, Gilbert BA, McDougall P (2007) International entrepreneurship and geographic location: an empirical examination of new venture internationalization. J Int Bus Stud 39:267–290. 10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8400342 DOI: 10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8400342
Franke N, Gruber M, Harhoff D, Henkel J (2006) What you are is what you like—similarity biases in venture capitalists evaluations of start-up teams. J Bus Ventur 21(6):802–826
Franke N, Gruber M, Harhoff D, Henkel J (2008) Venture capitalists evaluations of start-up teams: trade-offs, knock-out criteria, and the impact of VC experience. Entrep Theory Pract 32(3):459–483
Fried VH, Hisrich RD (1994) Toward a model of venture capital investment decision-making. Financ Manag 23(3):28–37
Ghoshal S (2005) Destroying good management practices. Acad Manag Learn Educ 4(1):75–91
Gibbons M, Johnston R (1974) The roles of science in technological innovation. Res Policy 3(3):220–242
Gibbons R, Waldman W (2004) Task-specific human capital. Am Econ Rev 94(2):203–207
Gimeno J, Folta TB, Cooper AC, Woo CY (1997) Survival of the fittest? Entrepreneurial human capital and the persistence of underperforming firms. Adm Sci Q 42(4):750–783. 10.2307/2393656 DOI: 10.2307/2393656
Gompers P, Kaplan SN, Mukharlyamov V (2016) What do private equity firms say they do? J Financ Econ 121(3):449–476
Gompers PA, Gornall W, Kaplan SN, Strebulaev IA (2020) How do venture capitalists make decisions? J Financ Econ 135(1):169–190
Gruber M, Harhoff D, Hoisl K (2013) Knowledge recombination across technological boundaries: scientists vs. engineers. Manage Sci 59(4):837–851
Guo D, Jiang K (2013) Venture capital investment and the performance of entrepreneurial firms: evidence from China. J Corp Finan 22:375–395
Hambrick DC, Mason PA (1984) Upper echelons: the organization as a reflection of its top managers. Acad Manag Rev 9(2):193–206
Hambrick DC, Cho TS, Chen M (1996) The influence of top management team heterogeneity on firms competitive moves. Adm Sci Q 41(4):659–684
Hellmann T, Puri M (2002) Venture capital and the professionalization of start-up firms: empirical evidence. J Financ 57(1):169–197
Hoenig D, Henkel J (2015) Quality signals? The role of patents, alliances, and team experience in venture capital financing. Res Policy 44(5):1049–1064
Hsu DK, Haynie JM, Simmons SA, McKelvie A (2014) What matters, matters differently: a conjoint analysis of the decision policies of angel and venture capital investors. Venture Cap 16(1):1–25
Johnson RM, Orme BK (1996) How many questions should you ask in choice-based conjoint studies? Sawtooth Software Research Paper Series
Kaplan SN, Sensoy BA, Strömberg P (2009) Should investors bet on the jockey or the horse? Evidence from the evolution of firms from early business plans to public companies. J Financ 64(1):75–115. 10.1111/j.1540-6261.2008.01429.x DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6261.2008.01429.x
Karsai J, Wright M, Filatotchev I (1997) Venture capital in transition economics: the case of Hungary. Entrep Theory Pract 21(4):93–110
Khan AM (1987) Assessing venture capital investments with noncompensatory behavioral decision models. J Bus Ventur 2(3):193–205
Kirsch D, Goldfarb B, Gera A (2009) Form or substance: the role of business plans in venture capital decision making. Strateg Manag J 30(5):487–515
Knight RM (1986) Criteria used by venture capitalists. J Small Bus Entrep 3(4):3–9
Knight RM (1994) Criteria used by venture capitalists: a cross cultural analysis. Int Small Bus J 13(1):26–37
Kollmann T, Kuckertz A (2010) Evaluation uncertainty of venture capitalists investment criteria. J Bus Res 63(7):741–747
Kuhfeld WF, Tobias RD, Garratt M (1994) Efficient experimental design with marketing research applications. J Mark Res 31:545–557
Lu JW, Beamish PW (2001) The internationalisation and performance of SMEs. Strateg Manag J 22(6–7):565–586. 10.1002/smj DOI: 10.1002/smj
MacMillan IC, Siegel R, Subbanarasimha PN (1985) Criteria used by venture capitalists to evaluate new venture proposals. J Bus Ventur 1(1):119–128
MacMillan IC, Zemann L, Subbanarasimha PN (1987) Criteria distinguishing successful from unsuccessful ventures in the venture screening process. J Bus Ventur 2(2):123–137
March JG, Simon HA (1958) Organizations. Wiley, New York
Mason C, Stark M (2004) What do investors look for in a business plan? A comparison of the investment criteria of bankers, venture capitalists and business angels. Int Small Bus J 22(3):227–248
Matlin MW (2005) Cognition. Wiley, Hoboken
Maxwell AL, Jeffrey SA, Lévesque M (2011) Business angel early stage decision making. J Bus Ventur 26(2):212–225
McDougall PP, Oviatt BM (1996) New venture internationalization, strategic change, and performance: a follow-up study. J Bus Ventur 11(1):23–40. 10.1016/0883-9026(95)00081-X DOI: 10.1016/0883-9026(95)00081-X
McEnrue MP (1988) Length of experience and the performance of managers in the establishment phase of their careers. Acad Manag J 31(1):175–185
Mitteness CR, Baucus MS, Sudek R (2012) Horse vs. Jockey? How stage of funding process and industry experience affect the evaluations of angel investors. Ventur Cap 14(4):241–267. 10.1080/13691066.2012.689474 DOI: 10.1080/13691066.2012.689474
Murnieks CY, Haynie JM, Wiltbank RE, Harting T (2011) I like how you think: similarity as an interaction bias in the investor-entrepreneur dyad. J Manage Stud 48(7):1533–1561
Muzyka D, Birley S, Leleux B (1996) Trade-offs in the investment decisions of european venture capitalists. J Bus Ventur 11(4):273–287
Naulin T, Moritz A (2021) Value-adding impact of accelerators on startups’ development. Int J Entrep Ventur (in press)
Oviatt BM, McDougall PP (2005) Defining international entrepreneurship and modeling the speed of internationalization. Entrep Theory Pract 29(5):537–553. 10.1111/j.1540-6520.2005.00097.x DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6520.2005.00097.x
Parhankangas A, Hellström T (2007) How experience and perceptions shape risky behaviour: evidence from the venture capital industry. Ventur Cap 9(3):183–205. 10.1080/13691060701324478 DOI: 10.1080/13691060701324478
Pelled LH (1996) Demographic diversity, conflict, and work group outcomes: an intervening process theory. Organ Sci 7(6):615–631
Petty JS, Gruber M (2011) In pursuit of the real deal: a longitudinal study of VC decision making. J Bus Ventur 26(2):172–188
Reuber R (1997) Management experience and management expertise. Decis Support Syst 21(2):51–60
Riquelme H, Rickards T (1992) Hybrid conjoint analysis: an estimation probe in new venture decisions. J Bus Ventur 7(6):505–518
Sandberg WR, Schweiger DM, Hofer CW (1988) The use of verbal protocols in determining venture capitalists decision processes. Entrep Theory Pract 13(1):8–20
Scarlata M, Alemany L (2009) How do philanthropic venture capitalists choose their portfolio companies? SSRN Working Paper. 10.2139/ssrn.1343563
Scarlata M, Zacharakis A, Walske J (2016) The effect of founder experience on the performance of philanthropic venture capital firms. Int Small Bus J 34(5):618–636. 10.1177/0266242615574588 DOI: 10.1177/0266242615574588
Shepherd DA (1999a) Venture capitalists’ introspection: a comparison of “in use" and “espoused” decision policies. J Small Bus Manag 37(2):76–87
Shepherd DA (1999b) Venture capitalists assessment of new venture survival. Manag Sci 45(5):621–632
Shepherd DA, Ettenson R, Crouch A (2000) New venture strategy and profitability: a venture capitalist’s assessment. J Bus Ventur 15(5–6):449–467
Shepherd DA, Zacharakis A, Baron RA (2003) ‘VCs’ decision processes: evidence suggesting more experience may not always be better. J Bus Ventur 18(3):381–401
Silva J (2004) Venture capitalists decision-making in small equity markets: a case study using participant observation. Venture Cap 6(2–3):125–145
Sitkin SB, Pablo AL (1992) Reconceptualizing the determinants of risk behavior. Acad Manag Rev 17(1):9–38
Slater DJ, Dixon-Fowler HR (2010) The future of the planet in the hands of MBAs: an examination of CEO MBA education and corporate environmental performance. Acad Manag Learn Educ 9(3):429–441
Tyebjee TT, Bruno AV (1984) A model of venture capitalist investment activity. Manage Sci 30(9):1051–1066
Unger JM, Rauch A, Frese M, Rosenbusch N (2011) Human capital and entrepreneurial success: a meta-analytical review. J Bus Ventur 26(3):341–358
Walsh JP (1995) Managerial and organizational cognition: notes from a trip down memory lane. Organ Sci 6(3):280–321
Walske JM, Zacharakis A (2009) Genetically engineered: why some venture capital firms are more successful than others. Entrep Theory Pract 33(1):297–318. 10.1111/j.1540-6520.2008.00290.x DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6520.2008.00290.x
Wang G, Holmes RM, Oh IS, Zhu W (2016) Do CEOs matter to firm strategic actions and firm performance? A meta-analytic investigation based on upper echelons theory. Pers Psychol 69(4):775–862
Warnick BJ, Murnieks CY, McMullen JS, Brooks WT (2018) Passion for entrepreneurship or passion for the product? A conjoint analysis of angel and VC decision-making. J Bus Ventur 33(3):315–332
Watson W, Stewart WH, BarNir A (2003) The effects of human capital, organizational demography, and interpersonal processes on venture partner perceptions of firm profit and growth. J Bus Ventur 18(2):145–164
Wiersema MF, Bantel KA (1992) Top management team demography and corporate strategic change. Acad Manag J 35(1):91–121
Wood MS, Williams DW (2014) opportunity evaluation as rule-based decision making. J Manag Stud 51(4):573–602. 10.1111/joms.12018 DOI: 10.1111/joms.12018
Woolnough BE (1994) Factors affecting students’ choice of science and engineering. Int J Sci Educ 16(6):659–679. 10.1080/0950069940160605 DOI: 10.1080/0950069940160605
Wright M, Robbie K (1996) Venture capitalists, unquoted equity investment appraisal and the role of accounting information. Account Bus Res 26(2):153–168
Zacharakis AL, Meyer GD (1998) A lack of insight: do venture capitalists really understand their own decision process? J Bus Ventur 13(1):57–76
Zarutskie R (2010) The role of top management team human capital in venture capital markets: evidence from first-time funds. J Bus Ventur 25(1):155–172
