[en] Despite still being a few decades in the future, the idea of establishing an extra-terrestrial settlement on another celestial body, being it the Moon or Mars, has never been so strong. Moving from the premise that future Moon and Mars settlements shall not take place in a lawless space, this paper addresses the question of how to develop and manage them in accordance with international space law. To this end, it conducts a systematic analysis of the Outer Space Treaty (OST), with the goal of assessing the scope of the freedom to use celestial bodies under international space law. Based on this analysis, and building on the successful experience of the International Space Station, the paper proposes the development of open international settlements made of shared modular facilities. In accordance with the principles of adaptive governance and subsidiarity, the paper argues that the regulation of such settlements should be based on a multi-level framework integrating international recommendations and bilateral arrangements. Under the proposed governance scheme, international recommendations should provide a general framework enabling the development of the settlement, while leaving its management to the mutual agreement of the parties. Finally, the paper presents four essential goals to be achieved by the recommendations and ultimately concludes by arguing that while international cooperation in the development and management of extra-terrestrial settlements is not a legal obligation, it may very well be the only political option that we have to preserve the peaceful uses of outer space.
Disciplines :
Sciences politiques, administration publique & relations internationales Droit européen & international
Auteur, co-auteur :
SALMERI, Antonino ; University of Luxembourg > Faculty of Law, Economics and Finance (FDEF) > Department of Law (DL)
Co-auteurs externes :
no
Langue du document :
Anglais
Titre :
Developing and Managing Moon and Mars Settlements in Accordance with International Space Law
Date de publication/diffusion :
octobre 2020
Nom de la manifestation :
71st International Astronautical Congress - The Cyberspace Edition
Organisateur de la manifestation :
International Astronautical Federation
Date de la manifestation :
from 12-10-2020 to 14-10-2020
Sur invitation :
Oui
Manifestation à portée :
International
Titre de l'ouvrage principal :
Proceedings of the 71st International Astronautical Congress 2020
Bryce Space, Projected Exploration Missions (2020-2030), available at https://brycetech.com/reports (accessed October 2020).
Elon Musk, Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species, 5 (2) New Space 46-50 (2017).
James S.J. Schwartz, Prioritizing scientific exploration: A comparison of the ethical justifications for space development and for space science, 30 Space Policy 202-208 (2014).
Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, Including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies, entered into force Oct. 10, 1967, 18 U.S.T. 2410, 610 U.N.T.S. 205 [Hereinafter: “OST”]
P. P. C. HAANAPPEL, THE LAW AND POLICY OF AIR SPACE AND OUTER SPACE. A COMPARATIVE APPROACH 9 (2003).
Stephan Hobe, Historical Background of the Outer Space Treaty, in COLOGNE COMMENTARY ON SPACE LAW: VOL. 1 14 (Stephan Hobe, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd & Kai-Uwe Schrogl eds., 2009).
As stated in the “Declaration on the fiftieth anniversary of the Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies.” U.N. Doc. A/RES/72/78 (29 Dec. 2017).
P.J. Blount, Innovating the Law: Fifty Years of the Outer Space Treaty, in INNOVATION IN OUTER SPACE: INTERNATIONAL AND AFRICAN LEGAL PERSPECTIVES 41 (Mahulena Hofmann & P.J. Blount eds., 2018).
P.J. Blount, Outer Space and International Geography: Article II and the Shape of the Global Order, 52 (2) New England Law Review 103 (2018).
Antonino Salmeri, The Regulation of Space Resources Activities Between National And International Law, 43 (1) Journal of Space Law 60-84 (2019).
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, entered into force Jan. 27, 1980, 1155 U.N.T.S. 331 [hereinafter: “VCLT”]
MAHULENA HOFMANN & TANJA MASSONZWAAN, INTRODUCTION TO SPACE LAW 17 (2019)
Article I OST, supra note 4.
Stephen Gorove, Freedom of Exploration and Use in the Outer Space Treaty: a Textual Analysis and Interpretation, 1 Journal Of International Law And Policy 100 (1971).
Use, in MERRIAM-WEBSTER DICTIONARY, available at https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/use (accessed September 2020)
Stephan Hobe, Article I of the Outer Space Treaty, in COLOGNE COMMENTARY ON SPACE LAW: VOL. 1 36-39 (Stephan Hobe, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd & Kai-Uwe Schrogl eds., 2009).
Ram Jakhu, Legal Issues Relating to the Global Public Interest in Outer Space, 32 Journal of Space Law 31 (2006).
Declaration on International Cooperation in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space for the Benefit and in the Interest of All States, Taking into Particular Account the Needs of Developing Countries, U.N. Doc. A/RES/51/122 (13th December 1996) [hereinafter: “Space Benefit Declaration”]
Stephan Hobe & Fabio Tronchetti, Free Determination of Cooperation, in COLOGNE COMMENTARY ON SPACE LAW: VOL. 3 333-336 (Stephan Hobe, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd & Kai-Uwe Schrogl eds., 2009).
Paragraphs 3 & 5 Space Benefit Declaration, supra note 21.
Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center, Benefits from Apollo: Giant Leaps in Technology, in NASA FACTS (2004). Available at: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/80660main_ApolloFS.pdf (accessed October 2020).
For a detailed analysis of the New Space economy see Marco Ferrazzani, The Development of a New Space Economy and of Mega Constellations, in INNOVATION IN OUTER SPACE: INTERNATIONAL AND AFRICAN LEGAL PERSPECTIVES 93-104 (Mahulena Hofmann & P.J. Blount eds., 2018).
Hobe, supra note 17 at 41. For a comprehensive overview of the evolution of the satellite industry and how it benefited humankind, see ANDREW J. BUTRICA, BEYOND THE IONOSPHERE: FIFTY YEARS OF SATELLITE COMMUNICATION (1997).
RTI International, ECONOMIC BENEFITS OF THE GLOBAL POSITIONING SYSTEM (GPS) ES 1-4 (2019).
Jim Brindestine, Life on Earth is Better Because of NASA, 25th September 2020. Available at: https://blogs.nasa.gov/bridenstine/2020/09/25/life-on-earthis-better-because-of-nasa/ (accessed October 2020).
BIN CHENG, STUDIES IN INTERNATIONAL SPACE LAW 229-230 (2004). See also Hobe, supra note 17 at 30.
Frans Von Der Dunk, International Space Law, in HANDBOOK OF SPACE LAW 55-60 (Frans Von Der Dunk & Fabio Tronchetti eds., 2015).
Fabio Tronchetti, Legal Aspects of Space Resources Utilization, in HANDBOOK OF SPACE LAW 781 (Frans Von Der Dunk & Fabio Tronchetti eds., 2015).
Philippe De Man, Exclusive Use in An Inclusive Environment: The Meaning of The Non-Appropriation Principle For Space Resource Exploitation 417 (2016).
Article XII OST, supra note 4. For a closer look at Article XI, see Cheng, supra note 31 at 248-251.
Fabio Tronchetti, The Non-Appropriation Principle Under Attack: Using Article II of The Outer Space Treaty In Its Defense, Proceedings of the 50th Colloquium of the Law of Outer Space 526-536 (2008).
The same conclusion can be found, with respect to space resources, in Mahulena Hofmann, Space Resources: Regulatory Aspects, in INNOVATION IN OUTER SPACE: INTERNATIONAL AND AFRICAN LEGAL PERSPECTIVES 202-203 (Mahulena Hofmann & P.J. Blount eds., 2018).
Olivier Ribbelink, Article III OST, in COLOGNE COMMENTARY ON SPACE LAW: VOL. 1 66-67 (Stephan Hobe, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd & Kai-Uwe Schrogl eds., 2009).
Fabio Tronchetti, Legal Aspects of the Military Uses of Space, in HANDBOOK OF SPACE LAW 338-341 (Frans Von Der Dunk & Fabio Tronchetti eds., 2015);
Tronchetti, supra note 68 at 340.
Sergio Marchisio, Article IX OST, in COLOGNE COMMENTARY ON SPACE LAW: VOL. 1 175-176 (Stephan Hobe, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd & Kai-Uwe Schrogl eds., 2009).
The M/V 'Norstar' case, Panama v. Italy, 10 April 2019, par. 199-ff.
Principles for a Safe, Peaceful and Prosperous Future. Available at https://www.nasa.gov/specials/artemisaccords/index.html (accessed October 2020).
Jim Bridenstine, Artemis Is Our Future, 23th July 2019. Available at https://blogs.nasa.gov/bridenstine/2019/07/23/artemis-is-ourfuture/ (accessed October 2020)
Guidelines for the Long Term Sustainability of Outer Space Activities, U.N. Doc. A/74/20, Annex II (20th August 2020) [Hereinafter: “LTS Guidelines”]
LTS Guideline C.1, supra note 84.
LTS Guideline D.1.3, supra note 84.
LTS Guideline D.1.5, supra note 84.
LTS Guideline C.3.3, supra note 84.
Jeff Foust, NASA Offers to Buy Lunarr Samples to Set Space Resources Precedent, 10th September 2020. Available at: https://spacenews.com/nasa-offers-to-buy-lunar-samples-toset-space-resources-precedent/ (accessed October 2020)
Jim Bridenstine, Funding a New Era of Space Exploration, Science and Discovery, 11 March 2019. Available at: https://blogs.nasa.gov/bridenstine/2019/03/11/funding-a-newera-of-exploration-science-and-discovery/ (accessed October 2020).
Jim Brindestine, Space Resources Are the Key to Safe and Sustainable Lunar Exploration, 10th September 2020. Available at: https://blogs.nasa.gov/bridenstine/2020/09/10/space-resources-are-the-key-to-safe-and-sustainable-lunar-exploration/
Tom Whipple, Space Chief Sets His Sights on European Moon Village (rocket salad optional), THE TIMES (June 20th 2015).
Jim Brindestine, Space Exploration Trascends All Terrestrial Borders, 14th July 2020. Available at: https://blogs.nasa.gov/bridenstine/2020/07/14/spaceexploration-transcends-all-terrestrial-borders/ (accessed October 2020).
Masahiko Fukushima, Legal analysis of the International Space Station (ISS) programme using the concept of ''legalisation'', 24 Space Policy 33-41 (2008).
The principle of adaptive governance has been at the core of the “Building Blocks for the Development of an International Framework for Space Resources Activities” published on the 12th of November 2019 by The Hague International Space Resources Governance Working Group. Available at: https://www.universiteitleiden.nl/binaries/content/assets/rechtsgeleerdheid/instituut-voor-publiekrecht/lucht-enruimterecht/space-resources/bb-thissrwg-cover.pdf (accessed October 2020).
